Thursday, March 18, 2021

Origins of the US Evangelical Right


Well, according to a Christian cowboy he certainly would be shooting me! 

There was an article in the January 2021 Premier Christianity magazine by Martyn Whittock, a Church of England lay minister and historian. He has written books on the subject of the association of American evangelicalism with right-wing politics (Witness wide support for Donald Trump among US evangelicals for instance). I was therefore very interested in the article he had written, an article entitled "The Disunited States of America". In the article Whittock explains why he thinks right-wing politics and faith have became so entwined in America. Below I discuss some of Whittock's ideas.

ONE) Whittock tells us that in 1954 the words "Under God" were added to the pledge of allegiance. He makes a point similar to that  which can be found on Wiki:

Even though the movement behind inserting "under God" into the pledge might have been initiated by a private religious fraternity and even though references to God appear in previous versions of the pledge, historian Kevin M. Kruse asserts that this movement was an effort by corporate America to instill in the minds of the people that capitalism and free enterprise were heavenly blessed. Kruse acknowledges the insertion of the phrase was influenced by the push-back against Russian and Chinese atheistic communism during the Cold War, but argues the longer arc of history shows the conflation of Christianity and capitalism as a challenge to the New Deal played the larger role.

Here was an early step linking Christianity with capitalism, low taxation, gun rights and the American way, a way which was set over and against communist atheism. These items then naturally became mandated in the Christian right's agenda. For myself I've always traced low taxation and US diffidence toward government regulation back to the very formation of the US in the American revolution, a revolution triggered by the a rejection of colonial taxation and suspicion of a distant central regulator. This history seemed to become ingrained into America culture; as Ronald Reagan said, "Government is not the solution to our problem, government is the problem. This ethos had the upside of helping economic growth via the market but the downside was an irrational suspicion of central government: Such attitudes do help create a power & influence vacuum which gives an opportunist the chance to step into that vacuum (which may be what Trump has done).

TWO)  In the 60s and early 70s there were government moves which were perceived as not favourable to the Christian cultural foundation of America. Viz: The banning of public prayers in schools, regulation of Christian academies, & legalisation of first trimester abortions. Quoting Whittock:

[Evangelicals] felt that Christian values were being overlooked, or caricatured, in the media. Furthermore, they felt that the school system drives a secular agenda. At the same time, the growth in LGBTQ rights challenged the traditional views of marriage and 'acceptable' sexual behaviour..... in short a cultural war began....

With this comment I feel I'm on familiar ground: My understanding of the rise of fundamentalist evangelicalism is that it is a response to the cultural marginalisation of Christianity especially during the 1960s (and into the 1970s) and especially among society's intellectuals who rejected the Christian rationale. In a reactionary move some parts of American evangelicalism became anti-intellectual and anti-science and the symptoms of this are seen in the rise of young earthism (latterly flat earthism) and fideist versions of Christianity that majored in the ecstatic. This was both a protest against the changing social mores and also against intellectual Christianity which was perceived to have failed. It was, I propose, akin to the response of the romantics, as puzzled but naïve Christians tried to regain a sense of sacredness in the creation and reaffirm the ecstatic component of Christian testimony. My understanding here has less to do with historical research than having lived through that time. But according to Whittock, because of conditions peculiar to the US, American evangelicals have also reacted by becoming very politicised and have expressed this via their support of the Republican party, a party which they perceive to be the party of traditional American Christian values. 

THREE)  Then in 2008, Barack Obama happened, says Whittock: He goes on to say:

The election of a young, intelligent, telegenic and highly articulate social progressive (committed to proactive federal government initiatives) was a sharp reversal of all that the evangelical right had been working on for more than 20 years. The Obama presidency was seen as an existential threat. Then the possibility of a political success for a socially progressive female Washington insider, in the form of Hilary Clinton, caused an upsurge of evangelical activism unparalleled in US history. 

FOUR)  Then in 2016 "Trump happened": According to Whittock:

It was this that led 81% of white evangelicals voting for Trump....It was a marriage of convenience in which Trump promised everything on the evangelical agenda.....Evangelicals reciprocated with intense support for a man whose personal and political morality  - which many feel is at odds with Christianity - was set aside in order to win what they perceived as a battle for the soul of America.  

His policy on immigration struck a chord, since polling reveals that 59% of white evangelicals see immigrants as threatening their cultural identity. 

For a group traditionally suspicious of government the necessary Covid-19 restrictions were often seen as unwelcome state interference.   In the same way, the shutting of churches was easy to present as state restrictions on religious freedom...the wearing if masks we seen as a sign of acceptance of state power. This occurred alongside a fear of economic decline as a result of lockdown, which further resonated with a group whose religious beliefs have long been associated with support for American free enterprise. 

....In the aftermath  of Trump's defeat, a well known US evangelical confided to me, in an off-the-record assessment, that the majority of evangelicals believe in Trump's narrative of a "stolen " election, a minority are resigned to a Biden presidency, but will keep fighting to change the abortion law; a smaller minority are relieved at Trump's defeat; and huge numbers of young evangelicals are leaving their highly politicised  spiritual communities. Clearly for US evangelicals the turbulence is far from over. 

***

It was almost as if Trump was stepping into a suit that had been specially tailored for him. The egotistical & cynical Trump exploited this situation to the full. He cynically made friendly overtures toward the crackpot professional conspiracy theorist Alex Jones and the crazy QAnon theorists - he was of course after the votes of their followers. The ultra-far right fascists and white supremacists were emboldened by Trump and crept out of from under their stones and appeared on the streets. Trump wanted their votes too and therefore wasn't vocal in condemning them. Trump talked the language that the right-wing wanted to hear; gun rights, low taxation, private health care, climate change conspiracy, America first etc; These things came onto the evangelical agenda and became almost mandatory adjuncts to their faith. Trump didn't care who or why people voted for him; he just wanted their votes, he wanted power. But underneath it he had complete contempt for the American system. He denigrated that system, its media and its governance with hints of conspiracy theorism and he attempted to bypass it with popularist rallies and social media. The Capitol Hill insurrection was a natural outcome of Trumpism whether he liked it or not. 

Trump had a sinister looking affinity & rapport with strong arm dictators like Putin, Kim Jong Un, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Mohammed bin Salman. If this was a sign (which think it is) that Trump had the qualities of a crypto-dictator then it is ironic that in some respects he stood for the very opposite of the things those right wing evangelicals elected him for: If allowed to have his way he was the antithesis of individual freedoms and small government. We saw hints of the kind of people Trump attracted when Michael Flynn, one of Trump's side kicks, suggested martial law be imposed to act on Trump's conspiracy theory that the election was rigged and force a re-count in Trump's favour.  But the survivor in Trump probably realised that would make America look like a tin-pot military state and blow his cover completely. The revelation of Trump's threatening phone call to a Republican election official telling him to find more votes or else, taken together with the Capitol Hill insurrection looked bad enough as it was! 

But the Christian right wing were blind to all this, blinded by their seeing the world through the paranoid spectacles of proto-Conspiracy theorism. For them mild social reforms, liberal attitudes, government initiatives and regulation were seen as the harbingers of a communist plot. 

Trump cynically exploited a run down and culturally debased evangelical community just as he had exploited the crackpot conspiracy theorists like Jones and QAnon. In fact there is an overlap between right-wing evangelicals and conspiracy theorism  (See here).  But many evangelicals, whilst  claiming to support freedom of the individual are the very opposite of what they claim to be; their cultural instincts lead them to favour a highly authoritarian fundamentalism with its absolute certainties, demagogic preachers, "anointed" patriarchs and Godfathers who rule almost by divine right. The notion of epistemic humility is utterly alien to them. They have, in fact, strong autocratic instincts; you will sometimes hear that "A church is a theocracy and not a democracy".  It is unlikely that they would feel such antipathy toward  government if government was in their hands; the tail seeks to wag the dog. Suspicious of government they may be, but I doubt they would be so suspicious if their subliminally dominionist vision came about and they at last held the reigns of power; it would be Rome all over again. 

Some right wing evangelicals attempted to excuse their support for a candidate of clearly compromised political and personal morality by likening him to Cyrus or King Jehu, Biblical figures who worked out God's plans in spite of themselves. That right-wing evangelicals drew this parallel is revealing of their autocratic tendencies: Cyrus and Jehu were Middle Eastern despots at the centre of monarchical systems, circumstances hardly paralleled in democratic America. Right wing evangelicalism's subliminally monocratic vision  of government was no model for democracy. I felt a certain amount of dubiousness when one citizen supporter of Trump told me that he believed the "Republic was being rebirthed".  On the news I heard another Trump supporter saying they wanted Trump to set up a Trump dynasty. So perhaps the "rebirth" was as a monocratic system with a Trump dynasty at its head? In which case it would no longer be a republic!

The much hoped for scenario of the right-wing evangelical imagination found expression in a solid wall of "charismatic prophecies" that wrongly predicted a Trump electoral win**. Well, if there had been a Trump win I can tell them this: According to Tolkien only one hand can wear the ring of absolute power, the one ring to rule them all.  That's why we have democracy instead of "Theocracy": Democracy attempts to distribute the power among epistemically and morally flawed humanity and forces them to give public account of themselves to one another. This may lead to untidy, messy and argumentative government, but such a system acknowledges that humanity is flawed, epistemically and morally, so that's to be expected. The fundamentalist kindergarten versions of Christianity abdicate their epistemic responsibilities and look for security & certainty and seek to end argument & debate with what they claim to be channels of unambiguous  divine revelation either in the form of so-called "plain readings" of scripture and/or the rule of "anointed" patriarchs. 

Relevant Links

The wasting of the evangelical mind


Footnote

** The news from America is that all the influential "charismatic prophets" wrongly predicted a Trump election win.  This systematic error is evidence of a systemic problem: One might argue that since we would stop listening to one prophet who got it wrong on many prophecies why should we listen to an ensemble of culturally related prophets all of whom got it wrong on one prophecy? One commentator on the failed Trump prophecies expressed his belief that some of the "prophets" had a good track record and were respected Charismatic patriarchs & therefore still worth listening too. But for me, given the sectarian complexity of evangelical culture, life's far too short to rake through this extensive and varied culture and make such fine tuned distinctions, if indeed they exist as substantive distinctions. I've got better things to do.


ADDENDUM 07/09/21

If the possibility of fundamentalist dominionists being at the head of a Western dictatorship seems farfetched let’s recall that many American Christian fundamentalists are closely linked to Donald Trump the man who:

a) Vowed to “drain the swamp” of America’s well established democratic government,

b) Attempted to by-pass established democratic institutions and set up his alternatives,

c) Hobnobbed with professional conspiracy theorist Alex Jones and gave credence to the QAnon theorists,

d) Seeded the democratic debate with conspiracy theories,

e) Arguably helped provoke the attack on Capitol Hill,

f) Emboldened race supremacists & fascists, (cf. the Charlottesville rally)

g) Had a rapport with dictators like Russia’s Putin (etc) 

h) Attempted to intimidate a republican election official into falsifying the vote count 

i) Had an adviser who suggested imposing Trump’s view of the election using military force.  


ADDENDUM 09/09/2021

In an address that can be seen here Steve Bannon, one of Trump's pardoned side kicks uses language that almost sounds as if he wants the 2024 US election to be the inauguration of a new dictatorship: He talks of 20k shock troops on standby ready to take over a country they effectively already control.....

If you’re going to take over the administrative state and deconstruct it, then you have to have shock troops prepared to take it over immediately .....pre-trained teams ready to jump into federal agencies.... .We’re winning big in 2024 and we need to get ready now.......We control the country. We’ve got to start acting like it. And one way we’re going to act like it, we’re not going to have 4,000 (shock troops) ready to go, we’re going to have 20,000 ready to go and we’re going to pick the 4,000 best and most ready in every single department.

Perhaps it's all just metaphorical election talk. I hope it is, but do people like Bannon talk in metaphors?  If the far-right win the 2024 election would they ever again concede an electoral defeat if they think of themselves as controlling the country? Having crawled over the back of Trump could Bannon one day call himself "president"?


News Monitor
On Steve Bannon:

Trump to start social media under his control:

Friday, January 08, 2021

Hell and Hamnation Watch


In a post entitled “Are we wrong to call out compromise”* Ken Ham heaps his spiritual wrath on Phil Vischer (of "Veggie Tales" fame) and the Christian philosopher William Lane Craig for their old earth beliefs. (both have been targets of Ham in the past)

Ken has every right to express his (misguided) conviction in young earthism as vehemently as he wishes and one can’t complain if he speaks out when he sees professing believers teaching doctrines that he strongly believes are opposed to his interpretation of Scripture. But it seems that Ken is unable to do this without impugning the consciences and characters of those who would disagree with him.

Like Charles Taze Russell who founded the Jehovah's Witnesses, Ken has a big stake in marketing his views and his organisation. These business interests mean that when it comes to criticising those who disagree with him Ken finds himself caught between a rock and hard place: He doesn’t want to look like a Christian cultist who make their views a salvation test and yet he needs to maintain the strict exclusiveness of his version of fundamentalism which justifies his business interests. Therefore he tries to keep an ostensible but teetering balance between shying away from outright cultish exclusivism and yet keeping up an exclusivist polemic which effectively accuses critics of all but blasphemy. To this end Ken gives much lip service to the paradoxical view that, in his words,  young earthism isn't a salvation issue but an authority issue. Like other sectarians such as the Jehovah's Witnesses he goes on to apply that authority (his, of course) with a strength of language that doesn’t just express his strong belief in young earthism but which assassinates the spiritual character of those who disagree with him.  As I have shown before Ken has a very unpleasant habit of heaping spiritual abuse on old earth Christians. This latest article of his is no exception. 

At one point Ken mentions in his article Charles Spurgeon who, following the majority of mainstream Christians of his day, showed signs that he believed the Earth to be millions of years old. But Ken is so convinced of the persuasive power of his own views and the impressiveness of his organisation that he is sure that if he spoke to Spurgeon, Spurgeon would see the light:

 I think if we were able to give Spurgeon the arguments biblically and scientifically against an old earth today, he would immediately see that believing in an old earth was compromising God’s Word.

Well, Ken, it's easy to put your opinions into the mouth of a long dead person isn't it?  Putting words and ideas into people's mouth's is another of Ken's bad inquisitional habits: He'll put blasphemies into the mouths of contemparies who disagree with him today!  Ken's confidence in the persuasiveness of his own words and organisation reminds me of a confident statement made by the father of  the Jehovah's Witnesses,  Charles Taze Russell, who also made claims to his authority: Viz:

 "People cannot see the divine plan by studying the Bible itself. We find also that if anyone lays the Scripture studies aside, even after he has become familiar with them, if he lays them aside and ignores them and goes to the Bible alone, our experience shows that within two years he goes into darkness. On the other hand, if he has merely read the Scripture studies with their references, and has not read a page of the Bible as such, he would be in the light at the end of two years". (The Watchtower, September 15, 1910)

Let's be clear: According to Ken if you study the Bible and don't come to the same conclusions about the age of the earth as him you are at best a compromiser and at worst a blasphemer - in fact Tom Wright and Francis Collins have been accused of blasphemy by our Ken! 

Raymond Franz, ex-JW, wrote a  book titled "Crisis of Conscience" where he tells of the spiritual abuse of those members of the organisation who eventually found themselves in a place where they were at odds with the Watchtower Society, the JW equivalent of AiG. Viz:

During those two years, the motive character and conduct of persons who conscientiously disagreed with the organisation have been portrayed in the worst of terms. Their concern to put God's Word first has been represented as the product of ambition, rebellion, pride, as sin against God and Christ. No allowance is made for the possibility that any of them acted out of sincerity, love of truth or integrity to God.....An enormous amount of rumour and even gutter-level gossip has circulated among Witnesses, internationally. Faithful Christians with high standards of morality are accused of being wife swappers, homosexuals, hypocrites, and egotists interested in establishing their own personal cult. Older ones are often dismissed as being 'mentally disturbed' or 'senile'.

In the article in point we find Ken, typically, laying on the spiritual incriminations in bucket loads. He accuses  Christians like William Lane Craig and  Phil Vischer of many things. In fact we read that:

* They are eroding Biblical authority.

* They are compromising God’s word.

* They need to repent of their compromise.

* They are the thin end of the wedge of spiritual degeneration: for compromise in one generation generally gets worse in the next generation.

* They, intentionally or not, haven’t done [what is right] with a whole heart.

* They’ve allowed some compromise to creep in, and it undermines biblical authority in their own teaching and in those they serve.

* They are taking ideas outside the Bible to God’s Word and undermining its authority.

* They spread secular, pagan ideas—they originally came from people who rejected God’s Word and sought to explain history apart from God and his Word. Therefore, those who add these ideas into Scripture are compromising with godless, “pagan” ideas. (The basis of this accusation is false. See here)

* They are false teachers.

All these constitute the grave spiritual character assassination of those who don’t follow Ken and his organisation. Ken's  claim to not make his views a salvation test looks like lip service. As we have seen here and in previous posts Ken is doing everything in his power of expression to make young earthism all but a salvation test of contemporary Christians who dare to contradict him.  


Footnote

* See here: https://answersingenesis.org/blogs/ken-ham/2021/01/04/are-we-wrong-to-call-out-compromise.

Sunday, December 20, 2020

History Please, Not Hamstory

The authority and rule driven
Ken Ham
In the following post....

https://answersingenesis.org/blogs/ken-ham/2020/12/19/phil-vischer-veggietales-creator-responds/

......we find Ken Ham once again failing to acknowledge the Seventh Day Adventist connection in the origins of AiG's Young Earthism. I've looked into this subject before. See here:

https://quantumnonlinearity.blogspot.com/2017/02/history-no-more-like-hamstory.html

I've caught Ken peddling his distorted picture of reality on more than one occasion. See here:

 https://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2018/01/the-distorting-lens-of-fundamentalism.html

Let's also bear in mind that Ken is prepared to dish out quite severe spiritual abuse on those who disagree with him. He is looking more and more like a cult leader.   See here*:

http://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2017/02/holy-bad-mouthing.html

....and here:

http://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2020/09/calling-down-hell-and-hamnation-on.html

If Ken himself or if AiG are attacked he tends to portray it as ad hominem and/or an attack on Christianity. See here:

http://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2017/06/the-pot-calls-kettle-black.html

....and here:

https://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2013/03/hell-and-hamnation-ii.html

Also of interest to me is this recent post by Ken:

https://answersingenesis.org/culture/will-biden-make-more-secular-america/

In this post the innuendo is that Joe Biden's administration is in danger of ushering in the strong secular  measures advocated by a group within the Democratic party who call themselves  the Secular Democrats of America. Within any such party there are going to be factions with varying and sometimes extreme views. The Democratic Party aren't going to be an exception to the common human tendency toward factionalism.  The Labour party of the UK have all but Marxist factions within the party but the leader Sir Keir Starmer is certainly not a Marxist any more than the Catholic and devout Joe Biden is a strong secular atheist; in fact he's really disliked by the American left-wing.  So once again we find the Trump supporting Ken Ham offering up a distorted picture of reality; in fact needless to say Ken overlooks the extreme factions within Republicanism such as Donald Trump himself who has the CV and personal traits of a corrupt, lying, egotistical, conspiracy theory wielding dictator-in-waiting (See here) with side-kicks like Michael Flynn who advocate re-running the American election in the swing states using military force.  But let me not convey a selectively distorted picture of reality (as does Ham) and acknowledge that Trump and Flynn are not necessarily representative of other Republican supporters.


Footnote

* In this connection it's worth following through the links here to see how Ham spiritually abuses a Christian geologist who disagrees with him. 

Wednesday, September 23, 2020

Calling down Hell and Hamnation on Heretics!

 

Ham's Heretics: Wright and Collins!

The above is an online duet by famous Christian scholars Tom Wright (Theologian) and Francis Collins (Scientist). It is titled "Genesis" and Wright and Collins use it to affirm their belief in both Genesis and evolution. I have to confess I haven't listened to the song just in case I find it overwhelmingly cringe-worthy. In any case as the specialism of this blog is really all about a miscellany of fire and brimstone fundamentalists, sectarians, cultists and the religious lunatic fringe etc, the devout, thoughtful, scholarly and mild mannered Wright and Collins hardly fit into these categories! In fact although I don't necessarily agree with their position on evolution my perception is that the following inscription found in St Stephen's church in Norwich, describes them well; and that's saying something; fame, admiration and status can be difficult to handle;

A scholar without pride, a Christian without bigotry and devout without ostentation

Neither will I be commenting on evolution or whether it is possible to reconcile evolution and Genesis. Instead, much more in line with this blog's interest in catching strange fish is the highly partisan and holy-than-thou fulminations of the kind we find in the all too typical outburst of Ken "Hell & Hamnation" Ham who screams down divine wrath on Wright and Collins*. One can well feel the spirit of the inquisition at work in Ham's response as he slanders W & C by stuffing words of blasphemy into the mouths and minds of all those he accuses.  As per below I've used bold type to emphasise Ham's baseless, fallacious and extreme spiritual incriminations:

HAMNATION: BioLogos (the leading “evolutionary creation” group) recently released a video titled “Genesis” that says, “Oh, I believe in Genesis,” while they demonstrate that they don’t actually believe in Genesis.   ...........  Genesis and evolution simply don’t go together—the biblical account of creation (which isn’t just taught in Genesis—it’s confirmed throughout Scripture) and the naturalistic explanation for the existence of earth, life, and the universe are utterly opposed to one another.

MY COMMENT: Ham should really have put it like this They demonstrate that they don't believe in my interpretation of Genesis. In my opinion Genesis and evolution cannot be put together. But qualified and measured statements like that don't make for the convinced sensationalist sales talk needed by a  fundamentalist theme park manager who must make a show of hard selling his line of thought. Also, as I have said on many occasions "evolution", as currently understood, is hardly "naturalistic" (what ever "naturalistic" means) in that it demands very unusual up-front physical constraints to work. In fact under no circumstances can a logically contingent world such as ours ever be "natural";  God, having the property of Aseity, is the only entity that is "natural". 


HAMNATION: So if someone says they “believe in Genesis,” but they also believe in evolution, then they don’t really believe in Genesis. They’ve taken man’s ideas from outside Scripture and added them into the Bible. Millions of years and evolution don’t come from the Bible—they come from the mind of fallen man, and N.T. Wright, Francis Collins, and others are using those ideas to interpret Scripture. Really, they’re setting themselves up as the authority over God and his Word, and they are a blight on the church.

MY COMMENT: Once again a narrow minded and sales-talking theme park supremo isn't going to get involved with measured subtleties like meaning = text + context, an equation which implies that the Bible can never be absolutely self-interpreting. It is the knowledge base we bring to the Bible which brings it alive, either rightly or wrongly (hopefully the former). But of course Ham is spiritually conceited enough to think he's got a direct line to God absolving him of any epistemic responsibility for its interpretation. It is Ham who is setting himself up as an authority over God and his word.


HAMNATION: It would appear that by singing “DNA, shaping creatures from the dust and clay” that DNA — not God — is doing the work of creation. This would be consistent with an evolutionary worldview in which DNA (the molecule of heredity) is supposedly responsible for all the life we have today. This idea is, quite frankly, blasphemous. It steals the glory that belongs to God—and God alone—for what he has created. DNA didn’t create creatures. God created DNA (an incredibly complex information system) when he created life.

To say that God used evolution to create and then to sing this line is incredibly inconsistent . . . and hypocritical. An all-wise Creator doesn’t use the inept, bumbling process of trial-and-error (and death, bloodshed, and disease) that is evolution to create. Instead, he speaks and it is so.

 MY COMMENT: Even if evolution as currently conceived is the explanation for natural history it is misleading to claim that DNA is responsible for all the life we have today: Instead we would have to trace the causes of evolution back to the physical regime that only omniscience could create knowing its likely outcome. So Ham is factually wrong here, although I can see why a dualist mindset like his will think in the dichotomised terms of "God did it" vs "Evolution did it" and then use that canard as the basis for accusations of heresy.  But although I can offer Ham some leeway here he's not got the kind of personality that is going to give allowance for the mitigating circumstances effecting those who disagree with him - rather Ham is going to charge them with heinous sins of hypocrisy and blasphemous and no appeal accepted. I have an inkling that  as Wright and Collins are both respected members of the secular academic establishment this has got something to do with Ham's outburst; the Christian evangelical Trump voting right-wing are very suspicious of "deep government" institutions in any guise, tax funded academia included. And let's not forget that Trump has fueled the fires of suspicion by making friendly noises toward Alex Jones and the QAnon conspiracy theorists. Trump, the would-be dictator, like Ham, has a need to discredit and bypass the institutions of society and appeal directly to his support base.

Although I have reservations about standard evolution myself, I wouldn't want anything to do with Ham's ignorant and mindless inquisitional style condemnation of Wright and Collins.


HAMNATION: And not how Wright and Collins mean when they sing “for he spoke and it was so”—they mean God spoke and over billions of years, natural processes, guided by God, bumbled about creating life on earth as millions of creatures that didn’t quite turn out died out, dying and suffering, killing and eating, paving the way for new, more advanced lifeforms to emerge. No, when the all-wise, all-powerful Creator speaks—it really is so, just as it says in Genesis.

MY COMMENT: Once again Ham is over stating the random "bumbling" element of evolution and wrongly thinking of it as a "natural process". In any case chaos, suffering, fall and evil predate man; that's what the appearance of the serpent in Genesis 3 teaches us.  


HAMNATION:  They sing that God is grace and love, but they are really attributing millions of years of death, suffering, disease, and bloodshed to God. By saying God used evolution, they are really saying God—not our sin (which is what the Bible teaches)—is the author of death and the brokenness of creation. That’s not the loving and gracious God of the Bible! God sent his Son to pay for this brokenness and rescue us from the mess we caused because of our sin in Adam.

Genesis describes the paradise of Eden as the first home for humanity—before Adam and Eve’s sin broke creation. But in Wright and Collins’ view, Adam and Eve are standing on layers of sediment filled with fossils (the remains of dead things). This means, in the evolutionary view, they are standing on the evidence for millions of years of death, suffering, disease, and bloodshed. How’s that for a “bliss” that we miss? What kind of paradise is that?

 MY COMMENT: As is common with some fundamentalists Ham neglects Satan's fall and the chaos beast - but actually in a sense so does the Bible but for the right reasons. Viz: That the central and primary message of the Bible is the plan of salvation for humanity and not Satan's fall; the latter is mere context even though it alludes to an important cosmic event; this event is not allowed to upstage the Glory of Christ which is the central message of the Bible (Phil 2:1-11). Moreover, like other toy-town fundamentalists Ham fundamentally understates the problem of suffering and evil by glibly (and wrongly) tracing too much back to the Adamic fall.  

Although Adam did screw things up big time for humanity, a claim to be the originator of the Serpent and cosmic chaos is too big a claim for (wo)man. 

 

HAMNATION: ....BioLogos and those affiliated with them are leading Christians into error. Wright and Collins need to repent of their compromise with the pagan religion of the day, repent of not believing God’s Word, and repent of encouraging others to compromise God’s Word. They may sing, “Oh, I believe in Genesis,” but what they really mean is, “Oh, I believe in man’s ideas about the past and have added them into Genesis.” They would do well to heed God’s Word, “let God be true but every man a liar” (Romans 3:4 NKJV).

MY FINAL COMMENT: Notice that Ham automatically gives no credence to the consciences of Wright and Collins or concede that in their own very scholarly minds they have satisfactorily reconciled evolution and Genesis; like other fundamentalists Ham assumes that Wright and Collins secretly understand the Bible in the way that Ham does but are knowingly suppressing it; fundamentalists (by definition) assume their interpretations are "plain" and beyond doubt. This is  the assumption made by all fundamentalists (by definition) that I have met from the Watchtower through the Children of God to Ken Ham.  Ham is effectively accusing Wright and Collins of wilful, knowing sin. Such is the wrath of a Trump voting right-winger who fears and looks askance at the academic establishment, especially if, like Wright and Collins, they claim God's salvation! 

Ham's word is not to be identified with God's word but simply the word of Ham. He's used Romans 3:4 in exactly the same way the Watchtower use it of those who contradict Watchtower teaching. In any case it's worth noting the parallels between AiG and the Watchtower. Ken Ham is a theological dunce who has failed to draw out the anti-pagan lessons of Genesis 1 and instead distorted it with his town-toy "anti-science" and a pagan dualist outlook. He should apologise to Wright and Collins for his baseless and fallacious accusations of heresy.  Unfortunately. however, I see in Ham the spirit of the inquisition, a spirit which follows rules and fails to take cognizance of consciousness. 


***

Postscript

In a recent bizarre web encounter I have had with a fundamentalist who is plumbing the depths of unreason I actually started to feel that relatively speaking Ken Ham is quite a reasonable bloke! That AiG in comparison can seem a moderate outfit goes to show how far some parts of evangelical Christianity (if it's fit to be called that) have gone down the road of utter intellectual debasement and lunacy. In fact so much so in this case that I found myself recommending an article on AiG to the fundamentalist concerned! But more about that weird encounter another time!



Relevant Links:


https://answersingenesis.org/culture/believe-in-genesis-sing-two-scholars-who-dont-believe-in-genesis/

In the post below Ham attacks William Dembski and William Lane Craig, both of a mainstream evangelical persuasion. It's a sign of how Ham's theme park sales interests have pressured him into taking up an extreme position and is over-selling his fundamentalism.

https://answersingenesis.org/blogs/ken-ham/2010/07/19/which-southern-baptist-professor-proposesteaches-this/

Viz: 
A significant portion of my presentation will center around the teachings of William Dembski and others (such as William Lane Craig associated with Talbot Theological Seminary and Biola University) who sadly contribute to the loss of biblical authority in church and culture.


Footnote:
* See here: 
https://answersingenesis.org/culture/believe-in-genesis-sing-two-scholars-who-dont-believe-in-genesis/


ADDENDUM 20/04/21

The FB post by Ken Ham below comes close to accusing Christians like N T Wright and Francis Collins of idolary. It further adds to Ken's cultic credentials. (Click to enlarge).


Saturday, August 01, 2020

The Poverty of Prosperity Teaching

After the depressing series I've run on Bethel supremo Bill Johnson I thought I would end the series on a positive note: Well sort of....

Job and his "comforters"; Job's suffering didn't last but like all suffering,
when you are in it, it lasts too long!

As if to dispel any doubt that Premier Christianity  Magazine eschews the prosperity gospel we find an article in the July edition by the editor Sam Hailes entitled  "I was is in constant agony". At the very start of the article we read:

Eric Gaudion's story is an affront to the prosperity gospel. It contradicts the misguided belief that Christians don't get sick. It challenges those who guarantee your healing - if only you pray harder, obey more or have more faith.

Hailes then goes on to relate the story of Christian Eric Gaudion, a  Pentecostal minister afflicted for 22 years with acute haemorrhaging pancreatitis. As a Pentecostal he had no a priori principles which impeded him seeking and believing in prayer for miraculous healing, but....

...nothing seemed to work. "I had so much oil poured on my head I wonder that my hair ever dried!"

Instead Guadion had years and years of terrible pain and once very nearly died in the intensive care unit. There was psychological trauma too, for himself and his family. He was also tormented by Job's comforters...

...telling him to "pray about it" asking "Where's your faith" or even suggesting he'd been cursed. [These] were all examples of how poor theology can magnify a person's suffering. "The very worst was claiming I'd been demonised" Gaudion says.

Tell me about it! I once met a Christian schizophrenic who was told that he was in bondage to the demonic and he should have an exorcism! I'm really ashamed of many evangelical Christians with their crackpot superstitions and that's before we get to the Trump supporting Christians with their Covid 19 denying, conspiracy theory pushing and gun toting anti-establishmentarianism. As with Bill Johnson, if something doesn't quite go the way they want or expect they witch hunt until they find someone to blame. 

But then in 2017 the medical profession came up trumps. Gaudion had a risky operation that had only been done once before. In fact it was so experimental that the BBC filmed the 16hr operation. The procedure  would....

... remove his pancreas and transplant the islets that produce insulin in the liver.

It worked:

"I'm completely free. I'm no longer on opiates. I have no pain. I thank God that my life has been transformed". 

The article says that Gaudion has written a book about his journey, a book which grapples with the theology of suffering: It's titled: "Through Storms: A manual for when life hurts". The article in Christianity finishes with a final comment from Gaudion himself (alluding to Covid 19):

We're facing a massive loss and grief and I feel God's heart is with us in that grieving process; that he weeps over the losses and shares with us in the pain of all that's happening. We also know our God is a redeeming God. And he longs to work even in crises like this, to redeem, to restore, to rebuild and, ultimately to bring us through. 

As a rule I don't comment on the question of suffering and evil (I've really only ever done one article on the subject) as so much ink has been spilt on the subject already and in any case I feel that people like Gaudion are far better qualified to speak about it. Gaudion's story is challenging and humbling: Could I go through with that kind of suffering and successfully come out the other end? I'm afraid to say that I really don't think I'm made of that kind of heroic stuff, but it's good to know that some people are.

As I have said more than once, credit must go to Premier Christianity for their honest, candid and courageous publishing, especially as so much evangelicalism is in the grip of triumphalism, superficiality, self-deceiving sophistry and a distinct lack of intellectual integrity. I have at times complained about some of Christianity's occasional writers but I think I can say that on the whole we are dealing with an honest editorial team that doesn't overlook tricky issues and faces them square on. But otherwise there is a large swathe of evangelicalism badly in need of a challenge to its spiritual complacency, cloud cuckoo land fundamentalism, irrational fideism, elitist gnosticism and above all its selective gullibility.

Gaudion's story is a fitting end to my series on the self-deceiving spiritual spin of Bill Johnson.

***

For the previous parts see:


Tuesday, June 23, 2020

Prosperity Christianity Part V: Soft-cop theologian examines Bethel Biblically.


Mike Winger Soft Cops Bill Johnson. 

For the previous parts see:



The above video is an analysis of the Bethel movement by Mike Winger. He himself is a charismatic and is no enemy of Signs and Wonders per se. He's also generous toward Bethelism and doesn't deny that some of Bethel's teaching can inspire. I would call him a "soft-cop"; in fact some of the comments in the YouTube comments thread suggest he's too generous. But having listened to Winger I can only say that if Winger is a soft-cop then just how hard are those hard cops? I'll move onto a hard cop later on, but really who needs hard cops when we've got Mike Winger's devastating points of criticism! I would, nevertheless,  recommend Winger's video to anyone wanting to find out more about Bethelism. On second thoughts I think he's a "fair cop"!

Winger's Verdict
The following is my interpretation of some of Winger's salient points. This interpretation can be checked by looking at the video. [I have put my own additions in square brackets] 

Winger says he's watched 60hrs of Bethel video footage to come to his conclusions. He doesn't accept that they are a front for shadowy demonic influences and believes that Bill Johnson and his lieutenant Kris Valloton are Christians. He even accepts that real healings do come out of this movement. But he believes there is a lot of fake stuff coming out of it as well. He says that Bill Johnson's vision for Bethel is that of spear heading a world wide movement. Through what they claim to be an apostolic network they aim to bring revival to the world wide church after the image of their own concept of revival. Johnson believes this revival will come by proactively exporting their "Jesus culture". [It's true that the Bethel influence has popped up all over place!]

But Winger sees a mixed bag. He sees twisted theology, a theology which encourages its followers to be fake and to fake healings and prophecies. Johnson's followers call him an apostle although he never makes use of that title himself; but he doesn't stop his followers thinking of him as such.  [The "apostles" of the circa 1980s "Restoration" movement  adopted a very similar coy-strategy to their apostleship] 

Winger shows a clip where it appears that Johnson is saying that "teaching" has less to do with Biblical text than it does in having an apostle as a channel of teaching. He thus subtly shifts the disciples attention away from Scripture to the apostolic figure himself and his authoritative teaching. [Hence, the cut, thrust and ongoing contention of Biblically based argumentation is supplanted by the authoritative quietus imposed by the apostle, where the apostle is almost a kind of embodiment of the Word.... clearly a dangerous precedent given that only Christ himself has claim to the title of being the Word]

On healing Johnson becomes even more extreme: Using Galatians 1 & 2 he informs us that anyone who doesn't accept Johnson's claim that all must be healed is in effect teaching a different gospel! Johnson talks about Jesus being "perfect theology" which for him means we simply must follow Jesus' practices and in a literal sense do as Jesus did: To this end Johnson resolves the resultant contradictions with scripture by constructing a doctrine of "Truth priorities": For Johnson some things in scripture are true but other things are "truer". His lesser truth category means that Johnson can ignore or override, for example, the tribulations of Job in favour of his "Jesus is perfect theology" prosperity Gospel. [Johnson neglects the fact it is still our responsibility to interpret the meaning of Christ's life and therefore we can make no claim to having in our hands "perfect theology" when we study and follow Christ]

To further justify Bethel's prosperity teaching Johnson uses the argument that "God can't give what he doesn't have". Therefore God can only impart health and wealth because He only  has health and wealth - i.e. he doesn't have poverty and ill health. e.g. God doesn't have cancer therefore he won't give you cancer. Consequently Christians must be rich and healthy. Winger calls this shallow theology.  (And see Rev 2:22-23).  But did Jesus really teach a prosperity Gospel? Johnson uses Mat 6:10 to justify his position, but Winger says that this verse only finally applies in the fullness of time when there is, eventually, no death (See Rev. 21:4). In contrast Chris Volloton has said "No one in our congregation is allowed to die except of old age". So says Winger, Vollonton accepts that death does eventually come to Bethelites and therefore Mat 6:10 doesn't, after all, hold at Bethel! 

At Bethel it feels as though there are a lot of healings taking place. But they get round the fact that healing doesn't always happen by poor confirmation of healing and using a doctrine of "keeping your healing"; that is, if your symptoms come back you are told that you are "losing your healing" which then triggers a process of spiritual investigation & diagnosis as to why the healing hasn't taken. They also talk about "the fragility of the anointing": Bill Johnson's son has a hearing problem which hasn't been healed. Once again Johnson finds an excuse to ignore this glaring inconsistency: He says that it will ruin his own anointing if he thinks with critical awareness about this inconsistency. Hence there is pressure at Bethel to avoid thinking about negative outcomes because if you do then Johnson's says it may badly effect your anointing. Bethel, therefore, have many ways of explaining away and/or coping with apparent failures of healing and this includes encouragement to turn a blind eye if no spiritual explanation is available .[In effect Johnson is proactively barring intellectual integrity as a harmful influence on their fellowship; hence a gullible unquestioning idiocy is actively encouraged at Bethel - Idiots for Christ!] 

For Bill Johnson's Bethel any nice and positive sounding words that someone feels they should say are liable to be ranked as prophecy; but only positive, happy words are allowed. Negative prophecies are banned at Bethel.  Hence Bethel becomes the source of many fake prophecies. Bethel also has such a thing as "Destiny cards" which are suspiciously like Tarot cards. 

Bethel are trying to engineer a revival in their own image. They are a contrived movement. 

So that finishes with Winger's assessment. I now want move on to.....ressurection.



A Prayer for Resurrection
The ethos of unwillingness to face the tricky realities of Christian life with critical awareness recently had a very sad nemesis at Bethel. In a very public display the Bethel fellowship prayed fervently for the resurrection of the deceased daughter of one of their worship leaders. The matter was reported in a news item in the February 2020 of Premier Christianity magazine. But the affair also got a wide airing in the secular media; the full glare of public attention as the magazine puts it. The Christianity article tells us how for several nights Bethel held services where they implored God for a resurrection, but after a week they faced the heart-breaking and tragic reality of the infant's death. 

The article quotes Johnson's well known position on healing, a position which is based on the notion that Christ's sacrificial death has already "purchased healing" (A common theological cliche among prosperity healers),  a position that encourages a witch-hunt seeking spiritual pathology should God not deliver (My emphases):

"When he bore our stripes in His body He made a payment for our miracle. He already decided to heal. You can't decide not to buy something after you've already bought it.....All lack is on our end of the equation". 

Well, that tells us where Johnson is going to look for spiritual failure when his prosperity expectations aren't fulfilled!  And I don't think Johnson is the sort of guy who is just going to tell us that his church was merely trying to be obedient to Christ's command to raise the dead (Mat 10:8) as Christianity quotes him, and then leave it at that. No, rather than just shrugging his shoulders Johnson looks like a man who is going to angle for a source of blame. But one thing you can't accuse these Bethelites of and that is a lack of belief. So where is Johnson's theological logic going to take him?  Perhaps he'll blame those Christians who criticise his "perfect theology"? After all, those who criticise his prosperity line on healing will, according to Johnson,  be teaching another gospel!

But undaunted by Johnson's theologically threatening position Christianity magazine, partly through the mouths of various pundits, arrays a strong critique of Johnson and Bethel. It is in great contrast to the Christianity article I quoted in part I where the reporter seems to be a Johnson convert. In this latest article, however, we hear that: 

The episode was grounded in really poor theology....you just take little snapshots of the Bible and pick out phrases here and there to extrapolate these huge expectations to command how God should act in a situation......they were praying for only one possible outcome...A wise pastor would stand with the bereaved parents while also gently sharing that God may have other plans as well.....Many evangelical writers have expressed similar concerns....Bethel's theology results of a transactional view of God....God is seen as a genie who will always say yes to our requests if we just say the magic formula.....my anxiety is around the mental health of the parents and the wider community when the miracle was not forth coming.

But Johnson takes no responsibility for the event. He says that they...

...had no option but to ask for resurrection, because that was what Jesus commanded his disciples to seek after.

...and remember if you don't accept Johnson's view without qualification then you may be accused of  preaching another gospel!

Christianity magazine tries put a brave face on it along and the best gloss. The hope was that....

....this story would encourage small churches to pray for healing miracles not out of habit but in the hope that God may actually act....all Christians should trust God enough to ask for big outlandish miracles even if they don't happen.

I doubt it: More like it will make Christians wary of such public failure. The Christianity article still talks about "the struggle against the giant of unbelief". I don't see any unbelief at Bethel (although I do see a lot of gullibility). Talk like this will only create more unresolved conflict, loss of confidence, heart searching and guilt in the lives of believers about their "lack of faith". Pray for healings and miracles by all means but don't think they are a reward for faith and if they don't happen don't then embark on a witch hunt for a lack of faith and/or spiritual failure somewhere. So in spite of starting well, in the final analysis  the Christianity article falls down badly, yet again.


The Hard Cop
We find our really hard cop on this web site:

http://watchman4wales.blogspot.com/search/label/Bill%20Johnson

Now I'm not sure I would want to meet this guy in a dark alley because he would likely hard-cop me and accuse me of heresy as soon as look at me. But then Bill Johnson, as we have seen, is himself a hard cop who is likely to tell us we are preaching another gospel if we don't tow his line on healing. One hard cop deserves another! So here we go with our stern Watchman4Wales' verdict on Bethel and the Johnsons:

It is important to note that the Ffald-y-Brenin bookshop is also very well-stocked with the works of Bill and Beni Johnson, the Senior Pastors of Bethel "Church" in Redding, California. This has to be one of the unsafest "Christian" couples on the planet, their "Christianity" having all the authenticity of a paste diamond, with Bethel having far more in common with sorcery and New Age mystical spirituality than with Biblical Christianity. From gold dust to glory clouds, from falling feathers to fire tunnels, from floating orbs to a born-again "Jesus," from waking up sleeping angels to grave-sucking necromancy, absolutely anything goes at Bethel under the Johnsons' (mis)leadership.

The Ffald-y-Brenin bookshop can thus lamentably be seen to be recklessly disseminating to the unsuspecting an alternative form of faith that is assuredly NOT the true Faith, but instead a deeply fallacious mystical New Age delusion, a cunning counterfeit of Biblical Christianity inspired not by the Holy Spirit but by a subtle and seducing utterly unclean spirit, working stealthily out of the war-camp of the Enemy!

To back up the charges of necromancy we are provided with pictures of "grave-sucking". Below I  include these pictures with their captions: 

And here's Beni Johnson herself, soaking up the anointing of  C.S. Lewis's bones by lying on his grave in Oxford. She also uses a 528HZ tuning fork for prophetic purposes...




A group of students from Bill Johnson's Bethel School of the Supernatural engage in sucking up Evan Roberts' anointing from his grave at Loughor in South Wales...

Hard copping done! Need I say more? 


Summing Up
Large swathes of Christian culture lack intellectual integrity. In fact I've long since come to terms with the fact that Christianity as a faith is extremely idiot proof - that is, it has a high resilience to the large numbers of gullible idiots (some of whom actually classify as malign idiots) who enter the faith. But in spite of taking onboard hoards of these idiots the integrity and dignity of Christianity's high sounding cosmic message of salvation is no more compromised than is the majesty of deep space in the presence of a few deluded "grave suckers" who inhabit one small corner of the cosmos. If I didn't believe this there would be no Christian faith for me (See here and here). In fact the only other (intolerable) alternative to the Open Gospel would be to join one of Christianity's  mean  little "holy remnants"  of huddled Christian crazies who think of themselves and their sect as the one and only true church and all others to be potentially demonic. Like Winger I don't believe Bethel are demonic but they do have a high density of gullible stupidity in their ranks, a stupidity which allows people like Johnson and Valloton to peddle their prosperity gospel justified as it is by a shallow, muddled and incoherent "quip theology".



Stay comatose!
As we have seen in this series Johnson's strategy is to do what he can to block any self reflecting & self critical stance, a stance which is liable to endanger the Bethelist philosophy of comatose forgetfulness. Critical-think, Johnson effectively warns, may lead to the loss of your all-important "anointing". Any apparent inconsistencies of Johnson's philosophy with scripture are dealt with by a doctrine which ranks and prioritises truths so that some truths can be regarded as overriding other truths. (Winger rightly identifies this notion as gobbledegook). As Winger says Johnson has therefore found ways of preventing scripture as a whole of correcting his contention that Jesus' life entails a prosperity gospel. This prosperity gospel, according to Winger, flies in the face of Job.  The ultimate backstop to critical thought is found in the notion that apostles are a kind of incarnation of scriptural teaching. Hence when the chips are down they can pull out this authoritarian card in order to further help ease through their theology. A claim to authority is the ultimate device to stultify a Berean assault on Johnsonianism. This is, however, not an original strategy: I remember reading the restorationist Arthur Wallis where he claimed that the chief way restorationist leaders exert their authority is via their Bible teaching. Thus, in effect  they claim a special almost priestly right to interpret scripture authoritatively (for more on restorationism see here).

At one point in his video Winger remarks on how Bethel teachers teach in a cheeky humorous way. This can be seen with other popular teachers of this ilk; see here. A brash humorous quip theology has great folk appeal.

All in all Bethel have contrived plenty of auxiliary hypotheses for explaining away failed miracles and stopping critical analysis of this failure in its tracks. Let us recall, however, that Bethel is a highly predatory sect determined to stamp their image on the rest of Christianity: They are pulling out all the stops to spread Johnson's teaching. But they may now have pulled out one stop too many.  Like the Restorationism of circa 1980 its empire building appeal will eventually peter out. 



Note:

Wednesday, June 03, 2020

The Apocalyptic Imagination



In my last post I made mention of the apocalyptic imagination, an imagination fired by a sense of foreboding and impending doom. Although conspiracy theorism among Christian fundamentalists has spread like wild fire across the internet in recent times, a nutrient bed of apocalyptic fear (which helps catalyse conspiracy theorism) has been with us for a long while.  

To prove the point:  I was recently going through my back copies of the Christian magazine Buzz (which eventually evolved into Premier Christianity) and at the back of the June 1984 edition of Buzz I found this short article:

100 Years Back
That alarmist tendency in Christian culture will always be part of our make up. 

It is fascinating that a century ago, with the great American evangelist D L Moody bringing the biggest wave of revival to the country for decades, the Life of Faith magazine of June 1884 still wrote: "This day is a day of trouble....attacks on the truth of God and on Christian institutions are growing more persistent and determined.....The very foundations of all that has seemed stable and permanent are out of course"

.... here we have Buzz, like Premier Christianity, showing admirable self-awareness and self reflection! They were never put off by some of the complaints on the letters page they got from uptight and trussed up Christians!
 
This constant crying of 'wolf!' has a desensitizing effect and squanders the capital of trust. The Watchtower did something similar with their date fixing. However, short memories usually mean that all this gets forgotten!

Saturday, May 30, 2020

Agreeing with Ken Ham (!)

Ken has at least screwed his head on tightly for this one!


My first reaction when reading this post by Ken Ham was to agree with him. Here's what he says:
 

As employees are increasingly working from home during COVID-19, online meeting apps, such as Zoom, are being used more frequently than before. Well, these two academics (one from Michigan State University and one from the University of Colorado, Denver) are worried that the use of these online meeting platforms is "a ripe setting for unconscious bias.” Why? Because someone, they say, might put their wedding photo—of a man and a woman—as their virtual background and “unintentionally reinforce the idea that marriage is most fitting between opposite sexes.” (Actually, the only true marriage is one between a man and a woman! See Genesis 1:27, 2:24, and Matthew 19:4–5). 

What if someone put up a “wedding” photo of a gay “ceremony”? Would that be ok? Wouldn’t that be a “microagression” against those who reject gay “marriage”?

And what would they call it if an employee had a Bible or a picture with a Scripture verse on it in their background? No doubt a macroaggression!


Yes Ken, if your facts are right*, then you have a point! So, in just being ourselves we can be accused of microaggression! This meddling hegemony in people's lives is born of a paranoid line of thinking and reminiscent of the fears that drive the nastiest apocalyptic imaginings of many a fundamentalist - so often with the latter I can only meet their florid accusations of malign motive with the utmost surprise of "However did they manage to work that conclusion out?". In fact I've also had that sort of thing from the people of whom Ken is complaining: e.g. I've been accused of exercising "white male privilege"!  But unlike Ken I would see this as less to do with a plot to consciously oppress Christians rather than with a world view haunted and stalked by fear. Fear provides fertile ground for conspiracy theorism. Fear provides fertile ground for hatred.  When allied to tribalism fear provides fertile ground for strife. 


Footnote:

* Beware of Ken's handling of the facts. See here:

https://viewsnewsandpews.blogspot.com/2018/01/the-distorting-lens-of-fundamentalism.html

and here:

https://quantumnonlinearity.blogspot.com/2017/02/history-no-more-like-hamstory.html